Overview of Buttermilk Cafe
Menu Highlights at Buttermilk Cafe
Brunch Specialties
Buttermilk Cafe offers a wide selection of brunch specialties sure to satisfy any craving. For a Southern-style dish, try their Creole Breakfast. It features shrimp, bell peppers, onions, cheese, and roasted jalapeno grits.
If you’re in the mood for something classic, the French Toast is a must-try. Thick slices of bread, dipped in rich batter, are grilled to perfection. For a more personalized touch, the Create Your Own Omelet option lets you pick from a variety of fillings to craft the perfect breakfast.
Lunch Favorites
When it’s time for lunch, Buttermilk Cafe has plenty of satisfying options. The menu features American classics like sandwiches, burgers, and salads, as well as daily specials. These dishes highlight the restaurant’s commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and its focus on attention to detail.
Signature Desserts
No visit to Buttermilk Cafe is complete without sampling one of their signature desserts. The Buttermilk Pie, known for its creamy texture and delightful sweetness, is a customer favorite. For those craving a smaller treat, the Shot Glass Sundae offers the perfect mini-dessert to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Whether you stop in for breakfast, lunch, or a dessert, the cafe consistently delivers delicious homemade meals in a friendly atmosphere.
Beverage Selection
Coffee and Tea Varieties
To complement its menu, Buttermilk Cafe offers a delightful selection of hot beverages. Customers can choose from freshly brewed drip coffee, bold espresso, lattes, and cappuccinos.
For tea enthusiasts, the cafe provides a range of options, including herbal, green, and black teas. Each drink can be customized with milk, honey, or sugar to suit personal preferences.
Alcoholic Beverages
In addition to coffee and tea, Buttermilk Cafe also serves a carefully curated selection of alcoholic beverages. A refreshing Mimosa, made with orange juice and sparkling wine, pairs perfectly with brunch.
For wine lovers, the cafe offers a mix of local and international wines, including reds, whites, and rosés. Beer enthusiasts will also find a variety of craft, domestic, and imported brews. The knowledgeable staff can recommend the perfect pairing to enhance your meal.
Customer Experience at Buttermilk Cafe
Service Quality
Customers frequently praise the excellent service at Buttermilk Cafe. Reviewers on TripAdvisor and Yelp consistently mention the friendly and attentive staff. This commitment to great service ensures that dishes arrive promptly, and guests always feel welcomed.
Ambiance
The cozy and inviting atmosphere adds to the overall experience. The restaurant combines comfort food with an upscale twist, all while maintaining a casual, relaxed environment. With its tasteful interior design and comfortable seating, the cafe is perfect for both everyday meals and special occasions.

Eddie Prasauckas – 05-28-24 – Front Room of the Cafe
About Buttermilk Cafe
At Buttermilk Cafe, the dining experience evokes cherished family memories. The cafe aims to bring people together over delicious meals, inspired by scenes of lively conversation around a table filled with good food.
The guiding principle of Buttermilk Cafe is simple: serve market-fresh comfort foods prepared by passionate cooks. The menu is designed to offer a nostalgic yet unique dining experience for all who visit. With an emphasis on fresh ingredients and flavors, this eatery has become a popular destination in New Braunfels.
To truly appreciate the culinary offerings, you have to experience them firsthand. The welcoming atmosphere and delicious dishes create a memorable experience that keeps guests coming back. Whether you’re celebrating a special family event or enjoying a casual meal with friends, Buttermilk Cafe promises a warm and satisfying experience.

Eddie Prasauckas – 05-28-24 – Side of Cafe
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the operating hours for Buttermilk Cafe in New Braunfels?
The cafe operates from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. It is closed on Sundays. For holiday hours, check the website or contact the cafe directly.
Does Buttermilk Cafe offer any specialty breakfast items?
Yes! The cafe a range of specialty breakfast items, such as eggs Benedict. Chef Carol Irwin, honored as San Antonio Chef of the Year and Texas Chef of the Year, prepares all offerings.
Are gluten-free options available?
We recommend contacting Buttermilk Cafe directly at 830-625-8700 to inquire about specific gluten-free options.
What are the best dishes for first-time visitors?
For a first-time visit, eggs Benedict is a must-try. This popular specialty breakfast item showcases the cafe’s commitment to comfort food with an upscale twist.

Eddie Prasauckas – 05-28-24 – Large Back Room of Cafe